Epistemic theory of vagueness

Author: hlmh

August undefined, 2024

WebThis essay defends an epistemicist response to the phenomenon of vagueness concerning moral terms. I outline a traditional model of -- and then two novel approaches to -- epistemicism about moral predicates, and I demonstrate how the foregoing are able to provide robust explanations of the source of moral, as epistemic, indeterminacy. Webvagueness. II. The Epistemic Theory Defined and Motivated Timothy Williamson, in a precis of Vagueness, defines the epistemic theory thus: it's the thesis that the proposition a …

Thinking precisely about vagueness: an interview with Anna …

WebThat highly controversial claim is central to the epistemic theory of vagueness, which holds that borderline cases are distinguished by a special kind of obstacle to knowing the truth-value of the statement. But this paper is not a defence of the epistemic theory. WebAbstract. Bonini et al. [2] present psychological data that they take to support an ‘epistemic’ account of how vague predicates are used in natural language. We argue that their data … shortcut enter keyboard

Epistemology Philosophy The University of Sheffield

Webof the other theories, the harder it will be to avoid the epistemic theory. The theory may be strange (but then 'the truth about vagueness must be strange', p. 166); however, it is not simply a last resort. For one thing, there is a general argument for bivalence, based on Tarski' schema, and biva- WebJul 10, 2024 · I was reading The Outer Limits of Reason: What Science, Mathematics, and Logic Cannot Tell Us by Noson S. Yanofsky and in some paragraphs of this books, The … WebDec 4, 2014 · The epistemic theorist claims that classical logic holds for ordinary language, but on the degree theorist’s account we need to construct a new sort of logic that works with degrees of truth rather than simply truth and falsity. The answer to the question ‘how should we reason’ has a wide-reaching effect on philosophical work. sandys on the beach

Downloadable Free PDFs The Semantic Paradoxes And The …

Sorites Paradox (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Winter 2005 …

WebJan 1, 2024 · Taking vagueness to be an epistemic phenomenon precludes the sense of agency needed for moral responsibility; taking it to be semantic does not. Thus I advance two arguments for semantic approaches to vagueness, as against epistemic approaches: one descriptive and one normative. Type Articles Information WebMar 1, 2001 · Vagueness in Law Timothy A. O. Endicott First work to integrate philosophical arguments over the nature of vagueness with debates in legal theory over application of the law in `borderline cases' Argues that legal systems necessarily contain vague laws Gives a new account of the relation between incommensurability and … shortcut enter today’s date iphone noteWebAbstract We argue that the epistemic theory of vagueness cannot adequately justify its key tenet-that vague predicates have precisely bounded extensions, of which we are necessarily ignorant. Nor can the theory adequately account for our ignorance of the truth values of borderline cases. shortcut enter in excel

"WebAnna Mahtani is an Associate Professor in the Department of Philosophy, Logic and Scientific Method at the London School of Economics and Political Science.. She completed her PhD on the Epistemic Theory of Vagueness at the University of Sheffield in 2005. She then took up a British Academy Postdoc at the University of Oxford, before moving to the … " - Epistemic theory of vagueness

Epistemic theory of vagueness

On the Psychology of Truth-Gaps SpringerLink

WebThe Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. Stephen Schiffer - 1999 - Philosophical Perspectives 13:481-503. Review: Précis of Vagueness. [REVIEW] Timothy Williamson - 1997 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 57 (4):921 - 928. Schiffer on the Epistemic Theory of Vagueness.

Did you know?

WebSchiffer on the Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. Timothy Williamson - 1999 - Philosophical Perspectives 13:505-517. Varieties of Vagueness. Trenton Merricks - 2001 - Philosophy … WebSep 28, 2000 · Her discussion ranges widely and comprehensively over the main theories of vagueness and their supporting arguments, and she offers a powerful and original …

WebAfter classifying sources of vagueness for ‘know,’ I spend the second section examining theories of vagueness. With the exception of the theory that vague predicates are … WebEpistemology is the theory of knowledge. It is concerned with the mind’s relation to reality. What is it for this relation to be one of knowledge? Do we know things? And if we do, how and when do we know things? These questions, and so the field of epistemology, is as old as philosophy itself.

WebAfter classifying sources of vagueness for ‘know,’ I spend the second section examining theories of vagueness. With the exception of the theory that vague predicates are incoherent, which I try to refute, we need not take a stand on a particular theory to show that the vagueness of knowledge has substantive epistemological implications. WebAny theory of vagueness must offer some solution to this paradox. Some of the most popular theories of vagueness include supervaluationism, the degree theory of truth and the epistemic theory, and many of the available theories demand a radical rethink of classical accounts of logic and language. Share Cite Print

WebAug 11, 2009 · Sider addresses roughly three types of criteria God might use to determine admittance into Heaven: (1) works, (2) faith, and (3) grace. He argues that each notion admits of borderline cases and thus is subject to the type of vagueness objection above. First, it is clear that any viable works criterion will have borderline cases.

Web1 According to the epistemic theory of vagueness (mostly developed by Timothy Williamson Vague-ness), there is a fact of the matter about the application of vague … sandy song grease liveWebThe epistemic theory claims that, in every sorites series, there is a counter-instance to the tolerance principle. The semanticist theories claim that the tolerance principle is false, or not altogether true, or that its truth is indeterminate, but they deny that there is generally any single counter-instance to the tolerance principle. sandys on the beach huntington beachWebThis chapter addresses the epistemic theory of vagueness, which claims that there are sharp, unknowable boundaries to the application of vague expressions. Some … sandy south carolinaWebFeb 10, 2010 · This book defends the epistemic theory of vagueness, which maintains that vague predicates do have sharp boundaries, we just do not know where those … short cute notesWebChrysippus and the Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. Susanne Bobzien- 2002- Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society102 (1):217-238. Horgan on Vagueness. Timothy Williamson- 2002- Grazer Philosophische Studien63 (1):273-285. Universalism, Four Dimensionalism, and Vagueness. Hud Hudson- 2000- Philosophy and … sandys on the beach redford menuWebJun 21, 2006 · Epistemic paradoxes affect decision theory because rational choices are based on beliefs and desires. If the agent cannot form a rational belief, ... –––, 2001, Vagueness and Contradiction, Oxford: Clarendon Press. –––, 2002, “Formal Problems in Epistemology”, ... sandys on the beach plymouth massWebJan 17, 1997 · In effect, the counter-intuitive aspects of the epistemic theory are avoided only at a cost to other intuitions. ... -schema is said to lead to absurdity (Williamson (1994), ch. 7). This charge applies more generally to any non-bivalent theory of vagueness coupled with the T-schema. If validated, ... shortcut entire row